| Year |
Player |
School |
Division |
| 2012 |
Michael Vine |
University Of Sioux Falls |
NCAA II |
| |
Gunner Johnson |
Butler |
NCAA I |
| |
Bryan Lopez |
Point Park University |
NAIA |
| |
Jose Hernandez |
Harris Stowe State University |
NAIA |
| |
Anthony Stewart |
Sterling College |
NAIA |
| 2011 |
Aaron Jensen |
Bethany Lutheran |
NCAA III |
| |
Homar Gonzalez |
Waldorf College |
NAIA |
| |
Brett Muron |
Bemidji State |
NCAA II |
| |
Jayrd Marks |
Bemidji State |
NCAA II |
| |
Steven Gonzalez |
Avila |
NAIA |
| |
Jose Stelluti |
Clarke College |
NAIA |
| |
Luis Reyes |
Clarke College |
NAIA |
| 2010 |
Ronnie Camacho |
William Carey |
NAIA |
| |
Jarcos Ortiz |
William Carey |
NAIA |
| |
Trevor Bartset |
Grandview |
NAIA |
| |
JC Burrell |
Eastern Michigan |
NCAA Div I |
| 2009 |
Nick Loftis |
University of Texas at Brownsville |
NAIA |
| |
Matt Leffler |
University of Texas at Brownsville |
NAIA |
| |
Chris Raley |
University of Texas at Brownsville |
NAIA |
| |
Fabian Cruz |
University of Texas at Brownsville |
NAIA |
| |
Andrus Kuilan |
Hannibal-La Grange College |
NAIA |
| 2008 |
Jose Ayala |
William Carey University |
NAIA i |
| |
Kenny Tomek |
University of Sioux Falls |
NAIA II |
| |
Jesse Strong |
University of Sioux Falls |
NAIA II |
| |
Michael Jimenez |
Clarke College |
NAIA |
| |
Adalberto Rivera |
Waldorf College |
NAIA |
| |
Trent Prather |
Buena Vista University |
NCAA III |
| |
Nathan Underberg |
Wartburg College |
NAIA |
| 2007 |
Craig Fandel |
University of Texas-Tyler |
NCAA III |
| |
Clark Egdorf |
Loras College |
NCAA III |
| |
Jason Kroese |
Clarke College |
NAIA |
| |
Brian Geertgens |
Loras College |
NCAA III |
| |
Jared Krasselt |
Clarke College |
NAIA |
| 2006 |
DJ Hasbrouck |
Buena Vista University |
NCAA III |
| |
Matt Mathiowetz |
Mankato State University |
NCAA II |
| |
Josh Rohrich |
Concordia St. Paul |
NCAA II |
| |
Matt Slattery |
Briar Cliff |
NAIA II |
| 2005 |
Adam Anderson |
Sioux Falls University |
NAIA II |
| |
Andy Cook |
Southwest MN State |
NCAA II |
| |
Matt Grill |
Sioux Falls University |
NAIA II |
| |
Gabe Hirsch |
Sioux Falls University |
NAIA II |
| |
Joe Joswiak |
Sioux Falls University |
NAIA II |
| |
Brandon Kathman |
Dakota State University |
NAIA II |
| |
Joe Larson |
Sioux Falls University |
NAIA II |
| |
Ben Long |
Sioux Falls University |
NAIA II |
| |
Tony Tysinger |
Sioux Falls University |
NAIA II |
| 2004 |
Nick Bruning |
Lipscomb University |
NCAA I |
| |
Cesar Camacho |
Grand View College |
NAIA II |
| |
Chad Cardinal |
Mayville State University |
NAIA II |
| |
Yadiel Fargas |
Clarke College |
NCAA III |
| |
Dan Wellik |
Waldorf College |
NAIA II |
| 2003 |
Carlos Aponte |
University of South Carolina, Spartanburg |
NCAA II |
| |
Josh Bay |
Morningside College |
NAIA II |
| |
Mike Koenecke |
Buena Vista University |
NCAA III |
| 2002 |
Jed Cox |
Sioux Falls University |
NAIA II |
| |
Dan Krohn |
Morningside College |
NAIA II |